Past Champions:
2012-13: Castleton
2011-12: New England College
2010-11: Castleton
2009-10: Castleton
2008-09: Mount Ida
2007-08: Mount Ida
2006-07: Mount Ida
2005-06: Mount Ida
2004-05: Mount Ida
2003-04: Mount Ida

Finalists:
2012-13: New England College
2011-12: Castleton
2010-11: Husson
2009-10: Mount Ida
2008-09: Castleton
2007-08: Castleton
2006-07: Castleton
2005-06: Castleton
2004-05: Castleton
2003-04: Castleton